Mutual Friends and Other Complications: Any Advice Helps

Okay, so it’s been nearly 3 weeks since my ex actually dumped me. However, it’s only been about 2 since I last spoke to her, and I’m feeling like I might have done the wrong thing in asking for more space and no contact.

The situation is this: We are both college students and met in college two years ago. We met in a common area on campus when she came up and introduced herself to me and my best friend. She disappeared for about a week and then came back around and gave us her Instagram tag to follow. She then tried flirting with both me and another friend at the same time, but I was the one who really took interest and sparked her interest. After giving her my number and texting a little for a whole day, I decided to take a leap and call her on a walk to my dorm. We then proceeded to talk for 4 hours, and she really got me to open up and be myself. I felt so comfortable talking to her. It felt like I’d known her forever.

Fast forward through the past two years, and we’ve shared several experiences, even that of living together for two weeks before getting financially screwed by our roommate and going back to living with family. Things, I thought, were still going great. We tried to have a break back in March of this year that really didn’t go so well. I acted needy and kind of desperate, but still got her back and things went well because we communicated effectively about what was hurting us, what we wanted from each other, and what needed to end. I thought that we were on a great track, and the summer was even better because we chose one day a week to get together. I even treated her to something special on her birthday, and rented a room for us for the night and paid for a movie. During the relationship, we really did balance things as much as we could to be equal and not have either one of us making more effort than the other. We also helped each other a lot with different things. She helped me to get my license by helping me practice driving, and I helped her as best as I could with schoolwork and giving advice on how to succeed in college since I’ve been doing it for four years now.

Fast forward to now, and the same problem she had in school persisted. As she has been struggling to balance both working full-time and going to school part-time, she would ask me for help with schoolwork at the last minute. Although she promised that it would change this time, it didn’t. She also gets very easily distracted with other things in life that make it harder for her to focus, and she has some self-esteem issues that she deals with due to family judgements.

Well… During the last two weeks of our relationship, I could feel that something wasn’t right between us. I could feel that she was opening up to me less and talking to me less. If I wanted to talk to her, I came across as needy. She started acting a little cold towards me, and I could not figure out why. On the day that she actually ended things with me, things had escalated at home between her and her parents who were telling her that she needs to make some big changes and start being more responsible. While I agree with them, the fact that it seems as though I was her biggest distraction from what she said to me- things like “I don’t want to disrespect my parents,” “I can’t love you and love myself,” “I need to learn how to love myself, and so do you,” etc.- make me feel like she left because she cannot think for herself. But, I digress, as I don’t want to come across as hating her or her parents. I don’t, and I didn’t want them to hate me.

We talked about things, and initially agreed to try to be friends straight out of the relationship. While I have accepted the breakup and all reasons for it, and I have started to look inside myself and work on my own insecurities, I feel as though she hasn’t, really. The thing that worries me is that she and I have the same friends, on social media and in real life. Some of our friends seem, in a way, annoyed by me talking about my feelings for her that are still strong. Again, we did just stop contact only two weeks ago, even though she broke up with me nearly three weeks ago. I was also the one who, on the premise of wanting to be mature about this and look at it from her perspective as well as mine, asked for more space from her knowing that trying to be friends after dating for two years and her ending things would not be any more conducive to us needing space or working on ourselves than staying in a relationship in which one of us lost attraction, connection, and trust with the other (which is exactly what it seems like happened). I was needy at the beginning in not wanting to lose her, and I even kissed her goodbye the night after she broke up with me. But, I took time away from her for a weekend and realized that we really do need the distance and space and time. I need to give it to her as she asked for a breakup, and I need to give it to myself so I can work on me. She also needs to give herself the space and time to work on herself if that is what she truly needs to do.

However, I’m seeing things that maybe tell me that I need to stay away from Instagram specifically (as that is the only social media platform she uses), and I am getting suspicions that our mutual friends know that she is doing things that will hurt her.
A mutual friend posted a picture of themselves drinking, and my ex commented “Same” on the picture. It makes me feel as if she’s just really not happy right now, and I feel like I should stop no contact and reach out and send her the elephant in the room text and try to get back in touch and spark a new connection with a new foundation. However, I did tell her that I wanted a month apart, and from the day we spoke and I told her I want more distance, it’s only been about two weeks. Should I break the ice and try, or should I stick to my plan and stay strong and contact her when I’M ready, not just on the premise that I’m worried for her? I’m open to the fact that even if I play my cards right, I may not get her back, and I may have to move on from her specifically. I’m also open to loving others, and I know that I have the capacity to find happiness in whatever I feel like doing for myself. I’m a very spiritual person, and I know that I cannot put my happiness in someone else’s hands. I need to want to be happy whether or not I’m with her, and I genuinely do. However, I see so much potential for a good relationship between us that I still want to pursue her.

What should I do? I’m torn.

It wouldn’t hurt to email or send a letter outlining your hopes for her future and concerns about her drinking and then try less contact after that. Her parents want her to be a more responsible person and get good grades in college. She’s young and sounds a bit immature, but as time goes on she will learn and grow through her life experiences. I don’t know how many years it will be before you and she finish college, but a little more time has to be devoted to studies rather than going out too much. It has to be a balance and hopefully she will learn how to manage the job, school, and maybe going out with you sometimes too.

Avoid talking with the mutual friends about her or your situation and don’t stalk Instagram.

Wishing the best for both of you:)

Update: I’m sticking to my guns of keeping NCP going for the next few weeks until I feel that it really is time. I may be a bit nervous about it, but I’m not fearful of the outcome at all. I know that whatever happens is meant to happen that way, and underneath the stress and struggles, we have love for one another that will never change even if some of our feelings do over time. How do I know this to be true? Because I’m wise enough to know that you cannot un-love someone. You may fall out of being “in love” with a person, but the love is always there because we as humans have an innate capacity to love and be loved inside of us. I know that there are days where I do not LIKE myself. And, what I mean by that is that I might not like certain nuances, like the fact that my hair is in that awkward middle phase of growing out and doesn’t sit right today, or I want to lose about 30 lbs by next year because I’d like to be at a healthier weight. But, even though I have things that I don’t like about myself, I still love myself and am happy with some aspects of myself and my life. Yes, there are areas that need improvement daily. Yes, there are things that I will find tomorrow that I liked more or less than I did today. But, I’m finding that I genuinely love myself, so much so that I’m doing things for me that make me happy. I’m expanding my knowledge of how to be successful and confident, I’m continuing a language study online for free, I’m continuing my studies in college (one more year left of undergraduate studies, by the way) I’m socializing with friends and being genuinely happy.

I’m not ending no contact until the month that I asked for is up. I’m not going to let myself stay in a stupor over things and not be happy. I’m my own person at the end of the day and I need to be happy. I don’t need to be happy with her. I’m happy on my own. However, I hope that I can someday still share my happiness and love with her. If not, well, at least I’ll still have my happiness and love to share with the world and the people in my life who bring me up, support me, and genuinely are the type of people I aspire to be like and surround myself with. The people with the good vibes. :slight_smile:

Update to that update:

So, two of our mutual friends that we would spend a lot of time with when we lived closer to them came up to see me last night. These two friends used to be a couple, but are now just really close friends who have worked on their differences and issues. And, we are all friends as well. Last night as we were all hanging out, my ex kept messaging one of them, my friend… Let’s call her Mary*. She kept messaging Mary asking if they could hang out because she was in the area. Mary told her several times that she was spending some time with me, and it might be better to get together on another night because of the fact that she wasn’t just going to up and bail on me. I told Mary that if she really wants to hang out, she can come and join us, but if it is going to be awkward, I don’t want her around. Well, Mary told me some things about what my ex has been saying to her.

I found out through Mary that my ex is considering dropping out of college. While it is ultimately her decision, Mary and our other friend, let’s call her Emily, made a good point. They moved and went to other colleges. Emily dropped out because she was getting too stressed with it and could not afford it, and she regrets it. She wishes that she had stayed and taken out loans to pay for it, because when dropping out, you can often lose the motivation to return to school. She is finding it hard to motivate herself to return to school, and does not want my ex to go through the same thing, especially if my ex wants a good career for herself that she sees in her future.

Mary also told me that she has been talking to her about how I’m “cool,” but she doesn’t want to get back together right now. While I don’t exactly want to either, she has also been telling Mary that it is okay for me to call and text her and be friends right now. I have told my ex that I do not want that right now, and the reason is because I have enough self-respect to know that it is not healthy for us at the moment, and I’m also trying to show her the respect of giving her the space, time, and BREAKUP she asked for. Now she is showing me through my friends that she is very lonely, lacking in confidence and motivation, etc. She also got in trouble with multiple speeding tickets on a night when she went to hang out with Mary, and is now fighting that.

Today, she even asked another friend for a hookup, and then brushed it off as a joke, saying “I know me and ___ just broke up, but would you like to hang out some time?” When the friend said “Sure, what do you have in mind?” she said “Maybe spending a few hours in your bed under your covers…” I was livid when she showed me, but I have now recollected myself. She’s lonely, and she wants attention, but she also wants a rise out of me. I will not fall into that trap. She’s not going to lure me with pettiness, loneliness, emptiness, etc. I’m sorry, but I’m working on me, and if I’m working on trying to be confident in myself and do what I need to do, why aren’t you doing the same when this is what you asked for? You’re only showing me that you want to push me away further from you.